About Bay Insurance: Florida Blue Insurance, Advantage Plans, Medicare Supplement Plans, Group Health Insurance by Blue Cross Blue Shield, BCBS
Serving Bonita Springs, Bradenton, Fort Myers, Lakeland, Naples, Sarasota, Tampa, FL, and all of West, Central, and Southwest Florida

Serving Florida for Over 35 Years

Throughout our history we have witnessed some of the most profound changes to have ever taken place within the health insurance industry. The implementation of the Affordable Healthcare Act (Obamacare) introduced a host of challenges as well as opportunities. The professionals at Bay Insurance have been active participants in the evolution of the healthcare industry, embracing new technologies that add value and efficiency and reviewing each new product introduction to determine its value to our clients. As your local Agency for Florida Blue, we have the distinct advantage of having access to a portfolio of health insurance products designed with your specific needs in mind.

We Work For YOU

While many changes have proven advantageous to health insurance consumers, others have not. Bay insurance has always taken pride in doing more than ‘selling’ policies as a health insurance agency. We take an active role in truly helping Florida businesses and residents in Sarasota, Fort Myers, Lakeland, Tampa, Naples, Bradenton, Bonita Springs and other communities throughout our state. This means taking the time to explain the intricacies of Obamacare plans, discuss the different benefits of various Advantage Plans, Medicare Supplement Plans and ultimately finding the right product for each and every client.

Our History

1985: Bay Insurance Tampa, 14426 A, Dale Mabry Highway (813) 882-3598

For more than three decades, Bay Insurance Tampa has provided the Hillsborough, Tampa Bay and surrounding area markets with a level of professional service and quality health insurance products. Our dedication to our clients and unwavering commitment to their satisfaction has earned us a consistent position as one of Florida Blue’s top agencies statewide, Meeting the needs of well over 40,000 clients. Bay Insurance Tampa is a proud member of the prestigious Diamond Club and a yearly conference qualifier since origination.

1986: Bay Insurance Lakeland, 731 S Florida Avenue, (863) 688-6659

Serving the central Florida area since 1986, Bay Insurance Lakeland has been the top-producing office in these markets since its inception. Bay Insurance Lakeland has served more than 25,000 clients, providing solid health insurance solutions to both individuals and businesses. Manager and Diamond Club member Rodney Pyle has over two decades of dedicated service with Bay Insurance and has the distinction of being a top conference qualifier each and every year. As an active member of the Lakeland Community, Rodney and his entire family are involved in many sports-related activities.

1989: Bay Insurance Ft. Myers, (239) 275-8500

Specializing in the small business markets, Bay Insurance Fort Myers manager Brian Walker possesses a level of dedication and genuine desire to help others that serves to inspire our entire sales department. From Englewood to Marco Island and all points in between, Bay Insurance Fort Myers has served more than 30,000 clients to date and that number continues to increase.

1992: Bay Insurance Sarasota, 2344 Bee Ridge Rd., # 102, (941) 922-9000

In order to meet the ever-increasing request for quality health insurance products and personal service throughout the Sarasota and Manatee County communities, Bay Insurance Sarasota was formed in 1992. Sales manager Mark Stoker and his agents continue to provide exemplary service to more than 20,000 clients while welcoming new customers to the Bay Insurance family.